A Cost-Benefit Analysis of the CFTC Case Against Jitesh Thakkar, Part 2

John Lothian

John Lothian

Executive Chairman and CEO

The Cost to the Markets

If there was a new prescriptive regulation from the CFTC that said every line of code written for any trading software must be documented as to its purpose and intent, there would be a hew and cry from the industry about the cost versus benefit of such a regulation.

If there was a new prescriptive regulation from the CFTC that said every person who touches a line of code for any trading software must have a liability insurance policy, there would be a hew and cry from the industry about the cost versus the benefit of such a regulation.

However, these are the new implicit regulations being written by enforcement precedent right now because of the CFTC’s persistence in bringing a “thin” civil litigation case against Jitesh Thakkar. Already industry code writers are documenting every line of code. And already, firms are considering whether to have liability insurance for their trading system coders. 

Already, this new implicit regulation has raised costs for participants in the markets. There is a new implicit regulation which is raising the cost of innovation. It is raising the cost of participation. It is creating a barrier to entry for small financial technology firms producing software for trading systems. And ultimately, this will be reflected in poorer quality of our markets.

I have made the case why continuing to prosecute Jitesh Thakkar is bad for the CFTC from a cost-benefit analysis, but here I maintain that there is a larger cost to the industry from this enforcement created regulatory precedent.

If there was a proposal in front of the CFTC for this prescriptive regulation, it would not have a chance of being enacted. The industry would fight this tooth and nail.

Instead, this battle is being fought against a strong-willed and proud software entrepreneur who is standing his ground and not agreeing to a plea bargain that would quickly resolve his legal problems and limit his costs. 

Jitesh Thakkar is not standing alone, though. More than 1600 people have signed the petition I created on Change.org, including some of the leading brokerage and technology executives from our industry. They are standing with Jitesh, not just because of the injustice of the case being brought against him, but also because of the cost of the regulatory precedent this enforcement created for the industry at large.

From a cost-benefit analysis, the CFTC should drop this case for its own good and the good of the industry.

To sign the petition for Justice for Jitesh, click HERE.

John Lothian Newsletter

Today’s Newsletter

We visit more than 100 websites daily for financial news (Would YOU do that?)

Now Read This

The Spread: It Takes Two to Contango

The Spread: It Takes Two to Contango

This week on The Spread – low natural gas prices lead to an increase in swaptions trading, the CME has another successful launch, and a Binance-backed exchange boasts a ton of trading volume.

…in with the new

…in with the new

This week on The Spread – the OCC and CME report cause to celebrate, bitcoin options products abound, and the options markets react to retaliation from Iran.

Nothing Learned from the CFTC Bullying a Win in the Thakkar Case

Nothing Learned from the CFTC Bullying a Win in the Thakkar Case

If Jitesh Thakkar loses his case brought by the Enforcement Division of the CFTC, it will not be because the facts in the case are damning against him. It will be because the CFTC has bled Thakkar and his family and friends dry of the financial resources and the will to persevere. It will be because the CFTC’s tactic of drawing out the process and the costs for deposing him, former employees and even customers became too much for Thakkar to endure.

CryptoMarketsWiki Podcast Ep. 7: Buy the Dip! Featuring: Thom Thompson, editor at JLN

CryptoMarketsWiki Podcast Ep. 7: Buy the Dip! Featuring: Thom Thompson, editor at JLN

JLN Editor Thom Thompson has decades of experience working in the financial markets in both the U.S. and Europe. These days, he uses his expertise to explain the cryptocurrency markets, especially the burgeoning cryptocurrency derivatives to JLN’s readers. In this episode of the CMW Podcast, Thom joins Matt in the studio to discuss the most notable moments in the cryptocurrency markets in 2019.

Share This

Share this post with your friends!