All Together Now: Exchange Leaders Call For Cooperative Approach To Changing Market Structure


Jim Kharouf
ssdf
U.S. equity options leaders said today’s market structure needs fixing and vowed to work together to address it at the Options Industry Conference in Scottsdale, Arizona. Among some of the structural problems are a perceived lack of liquidity, a rigid regulatory structure that has supported the fragmentation of markets, and a concentration of volume on a relatively small number of listings.
Kevin Kennedy, who serves as senior vice president, head of U.S. options at Nasdaq, called for the exchanges and participants to work together to upgrade the market structure so it works better and more efficiently in the coming years.
“We’re complaining about the regulator but it’s not the regulator, it’s the market structure we built,” he said. “We need to modernize market structure.”
Ivan Brown, senior director, options business team, NYSE Group, said that the marketplace is unbalanced, with 50 percent of the options volume represented in 22 just names. He suggested that industry try to make structural changes to the bottom 1,000 listings. Some on the panel proposed scrapping penny pricing on those listings. Others have suggested delisting illiquid names, but exchange leaders said there should be more incentives to attract trading in them.
Kennedy said that a committee of industry participants with a small number of objectives and a set time frame to complete them could be effective. As Andy Lowenthal, senior vice president, business development at CBOE said, some issues are “low hanging fruit” ripe for resolution.
The leaders also said that the industry should try to tackle auctions so that they work more synergistically with overall order flow. The multiple auctions processes used today offer choice, but there is concern that they are taking more natural order flow out of the market.
Whether Kennedy and the other exchange leaders can pull together an effective working group is unclear. But at least for a day, they seemed to be willing to address some major structural issues.
John Lothian Newsletter
Today's Newsletter

A ‘Mind-Boggling’ Individual Investor Boom Stirs Up Markets in Asia; Brazil’s Covid Crisis Is a Warning to the Whole World, Scientists Say
A ‘Mind-Boggling’ Individual Investor Boom Stirs Up Markets in Asia; Brazil’s Covid Crisis Is a Warning to the Whole World, Scientists Say
We visit more than 100 websites daily for financial news (Would YOU do that?)
Now Read This
Looking Back on 2020 with Phil Mackintosh, Chief Economist at Nasdaq
Phil Mackintosh, chief economist at Nasdaq, discusses some of the biggest takeaways learned from 2020, as well as what to expect from 2021.
Mike Cavanaugh – Open Outcry Traders History Project
Mike Cavanaugh found his way to the trading industry despite his degree in political science because he had a brother-in-law in the wheat pit at the CBOT. He did a summer internship working for “one of the more prolific wheat traders” and soon fell in love with the place.
Options Basics For Newbies: Mind Your Greeks, Professor Says
The well-documented influx of new retail investors into equities and options on equities in 2020 and 2021 has boosted derivatives volume, but it also has unleashed traders who may not be prepared for high rates of volatility if and when the market falters.
Explosion in Retail Options Trade Not a Short-Term Blip, Cboe’s Schwartz Says
In the current options market environment of rapid retail trading growth, data on who is trading what -- customer buyers versus firm buyers, that is -- is a hot topic right now. In fact, Henry Schwartz, senior director and head of product intelligence at Cboe Global...