CFTC Dismisses Its Case Against Jitesh Thakkar, Settles With Edge Financial

Thom Thompson

Thom Thompson


The CFTC is dropping all charges against Jitesh Thakkar in the anti-spoofing case that grew out of software development work that Thakkar’s company, Edge Financial Technology, performed in 2012 for Navinder Sarao. Sarao made at least $12.8 million by illegal spoofing, making him the most prominent trader to have been charged by the U.S. government for the crime. 

The proposed consent order was filed with the U.S. Federal District Court for Northern Illinois on Thursday. The court still needs to approve the settlement.  

The CFTC had not announced the settlement or provided any additional information on its website by this weekend. 

A petition, “Justice for Jitesh,” asking that all charges be dropped against Jitesh Thakkar, was launched last year by John Lothian, publisher of this newsletter. The petition on garnered more than 2,500 signatures from newsletter subscribers, traders, programmers and the public. 

The U.S. Justice Department dropped its criminal charges against Thakkar and Edge last year after a week-long jury trial in Chicago. The jury could not agree to convict Thakkar, splitting 10-2 in favor of “not-guilty.” The 2019 trial, which included lengthy examination and cross examination of Sarao, featured testimony from numerous experts as well as from the FBI. In light of the evidence given at trial, the Justice Department decided to drop all charges against Thakkar and Edge. 

Relying substantially on the same evidence as the Justice Department’s, the CFTC filed civil charges against Thakkar and Edge at the same time. Although testimony and other evidence provided during the criminal trial would not likely have been sufficient to support prosecution on civil charges, the CFTC’s Division of Enforcement proceeded against Thakkar last summer. 

CFTC attorneys asked the court for the opportunity to make their own case, telling 

Federal Judge Andrea Wood that the standard of proof for a civil case was different than for a criminal case. She allowed the case to proceed, appearing to become increasingly skeptical of the government’s efforts as the case moved forward.

CFTC attorneys deposed the former employees of Edge who had worked on the project for Sarao in 2012-13, in one case travelling to Toronto and hiring a translator for the deposition of the foreign-born programmer. In January, shortly before the end of the period granted by the court for discovery, attorneys told the court that they had agreed to settle the case. Division attorneys asked to depose 2012 members of the CFTC’s own Technology Advisory Committee, one of whose subcommittees included Thakkar, about statements he may have made to them regarding spoofing.

This quietly filed settlement agreement, the details of which have been impatiently awaited by the Chicago trading community, does not include any “gag order” unlike the agreement between the CFTC and Kraft from almost exactly a year ago. which famously did seem to require the commission to be circumspect about the results, was immediately published by the CFTC accompanied by several additional press releases.

The CFTC did prevail against Edge Financial Technology, the software development company. Edge, which no longer operates, agreed to disgorge the $24,000 in fees it earned from the work for Sarao and to pay twice as much again in fines. Among other things, Edge agreed not to sell the 2012 “Back-of-the-Book” program to anyone or include it in future projects. According to statements by Thakkar during the criminal trial, Edge never again sold the program, the design of which was specified by Sarao, to any additional parties.

The settlement with Edge does provide the CFTC with a victory in its controversial claim of jurisdiction over a non-registrant who is also not a customer. 

Final settlement of the 2011 wheat market manipulation case brought by the CFTC against Kraft is pending. 




John Lothian Newsletter

Today’s Newsletter

Pity Hedge Funds That Lost in Electricity Chaos — No, Really

Pity Hedge Funds That Lost in Electricity Chaos — No, Really

First Read Hits & Takes John Lothian & JLN Staff Rep. Jennifer Wexton (D-Va.), who has been battling a degenerative disease that has severely weakened her voice, recently introduced a new, AI-generated version of her speaking voice to her constituents, The...

We visit more than 100 websites daily for financial news (Would YOU do that?)

Now Read This

NYSE Executive Hyde Sees Retail Surge and Regulatory Hurdles Shaping Options Market Future

NYSE Executive Hyde Sees Retail Surge and Regulatory Hurdles Shaping Options Market Future

In an interview at the Options Industry Conference in Asheville, NC, James Hyde, head of business development and strategic partnerships at NYSE Options, offered insights into the current state of the options industry. The interview, conducted by John Lothian News as part of the JLN Industry Leader video series sponsored by OCC, touched on several key topics shaping the market.

When asked about customer priorities, Hyde highlighted the growing interest in short-dated single-name options in the equity space. “The industry is clearly focused on that,” he said, noting that a wide group of stakeholders, including representatives from the Options Clearing Corporation (OCC), exchanges, and the SEC, are actively discussing the topic. 

John Lothian: Week in Review (July 8-12, 2024)

John Lothian: Week in Review (July 8-12, 2024)


Clear Street’s Bold Move: Former Cboe Chairman & CEO Ed Tilly Joins Fintech to Revolutionize Clearing and Custody Systems

Clear Street, a fintech startup founded in 2018, is making waves in the financial services industry with its ambitious plan to revolutionize clearing and custody infrastructure and its big-name hiring of former Cboe Global Markets Chairman and CEO Ed Tilly. In an interview with John Lothian News, CEO Chris Pento and President-Designate Tilly outlined the company’s vision and progress.

Vermiculus Chairman Envisions Future of Exchange Tech: Microservices and AI Lead the Way

Vermiculus Chairman Envisions Future of Exchange Tech: Microservices and AI Lead the Way

In a recent interview at London’s Park Plaza Westminster Hotel during the FIA’s International Derivatives Week, Nils-Robert Persson, Chairman of the Swedish technology firm Vermiculus, shared insights into the company’s innovative approach to financial technology and its vision for the future of exchange systems.

Persson highlighted the evolving landscape of exchange functionality, predicting a significant expansion in offerings to members and customers over the next five years. He emphasized the growing importance of real-time risk calculation, made possible by new technology that doesn’t compromise on latency – a crucial factor for market participants.

Celebrating Independence and Competition: A Fourth of July Reflection

Celebrating Independence and Competition: A Fourth of July Reflection

We just celebrated the Fourth of July holiday and JLN continued its annual tradition of publishing the Declaration of Independence. I have always loved the beginning of the second paragraph:

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. 

As a writer who advocates for market-based solutions, I believe certain market principles to be self-evident. I hold that markets should be open, transparent, and fair. These were the values that the open outcry futures markets I grew up with strived for every day, in every session and trade. These values produced the critical concept of price, which was the most powerful news imaginable. They gave the markets and their prices integrity, instilling in traders a way of life that transcended the action of the trading pit. From this openness, transparency, fairness, and integrity came a greatness that spread throughout the world as different financial communities embraced derivatives trading.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This Story