Warning: trim() expects at least 1 parameter, 0 given in /home/customer/www/johnlothiannews.com/public_html/wp-content/themes/Divi/includes/builder/functions.php on line 12283
IDX 2021 Panel: The New Landscape For Clearing in the U.K. and EU | John Lothian News

IDX 2021 Panel: The New Landscape For Clearing in the U.K. and EU

Sarah Rudolph

Sarah Rudolph


With the U.K. and EU having recently separated, concerns about cross-border equivalence for trading and clearing venues have come to the fore. The clock is ticking down, since a temporary 18-month equivalence for U.K. clearing houses will end in June 2022. People are worried that the European Commission in Brussels may try to force banks to move all clearing of euro-denominated derivatives from London to the Eurozone, which would be too much for EU clearing houses to process. 

An IDX 2021 panel, “The Landscape in the U.K. and EU,” addressed this topic early Monday morning (for those of us in the U.S.).  The moderator, FIA Europe’s Bruce Savage, said the European Commission has said the status quo was “unacceptable.” 

Remarks of panel members included: There has been shifting market share and reduced market access for both U.K. and EU customers. Trading in euro-denominated derivatives has grown. A lot of U.K. trading venue activity has gone over to the US in the past year or so – about 2.4 trillion.  European CCP activity has grown from around 5-6% pre-Brexit to just over 10% currently and has more than doubled in aggregate notional value.

Daniel Maguire, group head, post trade and CEO, LCH Group at LSEG, said that at LCH, which is home to most derivatives clearing in the U.K., EU firms are trading and clearing more non-euro based derivatives than euro-based, which is polarizing the euro debate. 

“Denial of recognition will mean we end up with no choice and no competition,” Maguire said, adding, “Forcibly fragmenting liquidity will increase risk rather than reduce it.”

The FIA, along with eight other industry associations, wrote a letter to European Commissioner Mairead McGuinness requesting that the European Commission extend the EC equivalence deadline for U.K. CCPs past June 2022 and provide clarity “in order to prevent negative financial, commercial, operational and level playing field effects on EU counterparties and clearing members and to enable continued access to global pools of liquidity…”

The panel said it is very important that the EU develops its own primary market, which is what the revue of MIFID II and EMIR is all about. 

One panelist said there are many trading products available in the U.K. that are not available in the EU, and that it is proving difficult to build liquidity in EU products. “It’s much more complicated than just listing a contract,”  the panelist added.

Bank of America’s Emma West said there are currently market structure challenges in closing out positions, with no transferability between clearing venues. “You can end up closing a position on one CCP and opening it on another, which leads to market confusion,” she said. West also said local players will be more impacted by regulatory restrictions than international players. 

Maguire also said there is no indication from the U.K., of any move to lower CCP standards, and in fact the standards get higher every day. “Even if regulators decide to reduce standards, if you want to operate as a CCP in the EU, we have to operate to the highest standards – make the maximum we have to do our minimum.”

The panelists seemed to agree that the road to equivalence will likely be “more of a calibration rather than a tear-up-and-start-again,” and that everyone wants well-regulated markets with competition and less complexity. 

We visit more than 100 financial news websites daily (Would YOU do that?)

The Spread

Wall Street stocks steady after heaviest sell-off since 2020

Observations & Insight FIA's International Derivatives Expo is returning to The Brewery in London this coming 6-8 June. Standing still is not an option in today's evolving cleared derivatives environment. Without adapting to new products, processes, technologies...

Now Read This

Vermiculus Chairman Nils-Robert Persson on launching during a pandemic and structuring his company for growth

Vermiculus Chairman Nils-Robert Persson on launching during a pandemic and structuring his company for growth

Nils-Robert Persson, chairman of the board of Vermiculus Financial Technology, had no intention of starting a new company after leaving Cinnober in 2019. What happened is he was asked and he couldn’t refuse. “When some of the best people you have ever worked with, and some of the customers you’re extremely proud of working with, come and ask you to start – it’s easy to start again,” Persson told John Lothian News at FIA Boca 2022.

SGX Group’s Michael Syn on remote work, internationalization, and maintaining SGX market fluency

SGX Group’s Michael Syn on remote work, internationalization, and maintaining SGX market fluency

The Singapore Exchange (SGX) is the largest US dollar clearinghouse in Asia, and it is the largest RMB clearing house in the world outside of China. The work of SGX in 2022 is to maintain its position of fluency in dollars, euros, sterling and RMB, making sure access is open to participants from around the world, said Michael Syn, senior managing director and head of equities at SGX.

Pat Kenny, “the most interesting man,” in interesting times

Pat Kenny, “the most interesting man,” in interesting times

John Lothian News caught up with Pat Kenny, “the most interesting man in the world” according to John Lothian, at the FIA Boca 2022 conference in Boca Raton in March. Kenny is SVP of client relations for CQG, and he talked about CQG One, the company’s newest charting and analytics platform geared toward professional traders, and the effects of the covid pandemic on CQG’s business and on the industry.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This Story